Product Management Consulting: What, How, Why and When?

07 Aug 2025

Today, senior leaders face relentless pressure to deliver successful products in complex, fast-changing markets. Whether you’re steering a multinational with an international supply chain or a growing SME, the responsibility for product success can feel heavy. You seek clarity and confidence that your product strategy will meet customer needs and business goals. This is where product management consulting comes in.

In this article, we explain what product management consulting is, how a typical engagement works, why it’s so important in challenging business environments, when to consider bringing in outside expertise and what outcomes you can expect. The goal is to give you a clear, consultative understanding of this service, so you can decide if it’s the partner you need to drive meaningful, sustainable results for your organisation.

What is product management consulting?

Product management consulting is a specialised, strategic service where experienced product experts partner with your organisation to guide every stage of a product’s lifecycle. This spans from early ideation and market research through development, launch, growth and even end-of-life planning – ensuring that each product is optimiszed for market success and aligned with your company’s objectives.

It’s like gaining an on-demand product executive with broad industry experience, without the overhead of a full-time hire. Importantly, product management consultants focus on aligning three critical dimensions: customer needs, business strategy and product execution. A product manager typically sits at the intersection of departments (marketing, R&D, design, finance, operations), coordinating them to bring a product to market.

Explore our Demand Management Consulting Services.

When you hire a product management consultant, you’re getting an outside expert who can assess your product strategy, ensure it addresses real customer pain points and streamline cross-functional efforts toward a successful launch.

The consultant works not just on processes and plans, but also helps bridge gaps between teams, making sure everyone from engineers to marketers stays focused on building the right product for the right customer with the right business case. By providing an objective viewpoint and proven frameworks, they “smooth” your product development process and increase the odds that new offerings will thrive in the market.

At its core, product management consulting brings a full-lifecycle, end-to-end perspective. This means looking at how an idea becomes a product and eventually matures or retires and optimising that journey. It also means ensuring alignment at all levels: the product’s value proposition must resonate with customer demands and its outcomes must support the broader business strategy (revenue, growth, brand positioning, etc.).

For example, a consultant might help clarify how a new product fits into your portfolio and how it should be positioned to customers, all while making sure it will achieve the financial returns the business expects. The result is a more coherent strategy where product decisions are not made in isolation but are tightly linked to customer insights and business goals, providing the clarity senior leaders crave.

How do product management consulting engagements work?

Engaging a product management consultancy typically follows a structured but collaborative process. While every firm may have its own twist (for example, Oliver Wight’s trademarked Proven Path® method), most consulting engagements cover a series of common phases or activities designed to diagnose issues, align stakeholders and drive implementation.

Here’s how a typical engagement might work:

Diagnostic assessment
Consultants usually begin with a thorough diagnosis of your current product management practices and performance. This might involve reviewing your product portfolio, roadmaps, development process and outcomes to identify gaps or pain points. The consultant will speak with stakeholders across functions and examine data to pinpoint root causes of problems – for instance, why a product launch missed its targets or where in the lifecycle projects are stalling.

This diagnostic phase provides a fact-based foundation for improvement (often including a written assessment). In many cases, consultants will explicitly highlight issues such as unclear governance or process bottlenecks that need addressing.

Strategy and roadmap development
Based on the diagnostic insights, the consultant works with you to craft a product strategy and improvement roadmap. This typically includes defining or refining the product vision, setting priorities for the product portfolio and mapping out initiatives to enhance product performance. For a specific product, it could mean adjusting the value proposition or feature set to better meet customer needs; at a portfolio level, it could mean deciding which projects to fast-track or which legacy products to sunset.

Importantly, this phase aligns the product strategy with your business strategy – ensuring every product initiative ties back to business objectives like growth, profitability, or market penetration. The output is often a clear roadmap or action plan that outlines what needs to be done, the timeline, required resources and expected results. This gives leaders a concrete path forward and a sense of control and clarity over the product direction.

Cross-functional alignment and process design
Even the best strategy will falter if your teams remain siloed. Thus, product management consultants put strong emphasis on cross-functional alignment. They may facilitate workshops or planning sessions that bring together product managers, engineers, marketers, sales, supply chain and finance leaders to ensure everyone understands the game plan and their role in it. In a large enterprise with international supply chains, this alignment is critical – product decisions must sync with supply chain capabilities, marketing campaigns and sales efforts globally.

Explore our Supply Chain Management Consulting Services

Consultants like Oliver Wight, often help design or refine processes that institutionalise this alignment. For example, they might implement a structured product planning cadence (for example, Oliver Wight’s signature Integrated Business Planning process) so that new product ideas are evaluated with input from all departments and that updates on development progress are regularly shared company-wide. They could also redesign the product development process – introducing stage gates or agile methodologies, to improve efficiency and collaboration. The result is a set of product management processes and governance forums tailored to your organisation, ensuring that all parts of the business work in concert to support the product lifecycle.

Capability building and coaching
A hallmark of good product management consulting is that it’s not just a one-off advisory – it’s also about building your internal capability. Oliver Wight consultants will work side by side with your teams to transfer knowledge and best practices. This might involve coaching your product managers on new techniques (e.g. how to conduct customer research or prioritise a backlog), training cross-functional teams in new processes, or even embedding interim product leaders to mentor your staff. The goal is to enable your organisation to continue succeeding long after the consultants depart.

The aim is to transfer knowledge to your people, equipping them to apply effective product management processes independently. This focus on people – not just processes – helps drive lasting change. Your team gains new skills and a fresh perspective on product challenges, often feeling re-energised and more confident in their ability to deliver winning products.

Explore our bespoke private workshops.

Governance and sustainable implementation
Finally, product management consultants help put in place governance mechanisms and follow-ups to ensure the changes stick and results are realised. This can include establishing clear ownership for product decisions (e.g. defining roles for product portfolio governance), setting up key performance indicators and dashboards to track product success and scheduling regular business reviews of the product portfolio. Many consultancies will perform a post-engagement review or even certify that the client has reached a certain maturity level in product management. For instance, here at Oliver Wight, we have a proprietary maturity model to assess an organisation’s progress and identify if it has achieved “Class A” excellence, meaning the new product management processes are firmly embedded as the way “you do things” and consistently delivering benefits.

See how mature aspects of YOUR business are with our Business Maturity Assessments.

In other words, the consultant helps you institutionalise the improvements so that product management becomes an integral, self-sustaining part of your company’s DNA. This gives senior leaders peace of mind that the improvements won’t fade with the first setback – they’re built to last.

These phases often overlap and iterate. Throughout the engagement, a reputable consultant acts as a partner and coach – working collaboratively with your team rather than imposing one-size-fits-all solutions. They bring structure to what can be a chaotic situation, but they also remain adaptable to your company’s culture. For example, here at Oliver Wight, we might start with our signature framework but will tailor it to your business context, recognising whether you need small iterative improvements or a large-scale transformation.

The consulting team will regularly update leadership on progress, provide candid feedback (even if it’s tough to hear) and ensure that you, as a leader, stay informed and in control of the change. The end result of the “how” is not just a report, but an organisation moving in unison toward product and market excellence, guided by a structured plan and new capabilities.

Why is product management consulting important?

In today’s business landscape, effective product management can make the difference between leading the market or falling behind – and getting it right has become both more challenging and more critical than ever. Here are a few reasons why product management consulting has emerged as an important lever for companies, especially in complex or fast-evolving environments:

High stakes and complexity
Developing and managing products has inherent risks. The investment is significant – in R&D, marketing, supply chain and more – and failure is costly. Unfortunately, many companies struggle to get it right on their own. Studies have found that between 65% and 75% of new product offerings fail outright or miss their revenue and profit goals. That’s a sobering statistic for any executive accountable for product performance. The reasons behind such failures are often complex: markets change rapidly, technologies disrupt business models and customer preferences can be a moving target.

In large enterprises, complexity is multiplied by global operations and extensive product lines; in SMEs, resources are limited and one bet going wrong can be existential. Product management consulting is important because it directly tackles these high stakes. Consultants bring expertise and focus to navigate complexity – helping you identify why a product isn’t winning in the market and what to do about it. They help ensure you’re not one of those statistics by formulating strategies to avoid common pitfalls (like over-engineering features or misreading customer needs) and by steering your team toward data-driven, informed decisions. In short, they act as a safety net and catalyst, increasing the chance that your product investments will pay off.

Aligning products with business strategy
In many companies, there’s a disconnect between lofty business strategy and the on-the-ground product decisions. Strategies might call for innovation and growth, but day-to-day product development can get mired in technical tweaks or pet projects that don’t move the needle.

Product management consultants serve as a bridge between vision and execution. They ensure that each product or innovation initiative clearly supports the company’s strategic goals. This alignment is especially important in evolving environments – for example, if your company is pivoting to digital solutions, launching products in new markets, or responding to disruptive competitors.

Consultants help translate those strategic shifts into concrete product plans. They bring frameworks to prioritise initiatives (so resources go to the highest-impact products) and to kill or reinvent projects that no longer fit the strategy.

For leaders, this offers much-needed clarity: you can see how every product under development links to the bigger picture and you can confidently communicate to stakeholders (from your board to frontline employees) why you’re investing in certain product areas. In complex global businesses, this alignment also means better coordination – product strategy, sales strategy and supply chain strategy all rowing in the same direction.

Objective expertise and fresh perspective
Even the most talented internal teams can develop blind spots. It’s human nature for product teams to become attached to their ideas or for organisations to stick with “the way we’ve always done it.” Bringing in an external product management consultant injects a fresh, unbiased perspective into your company. These consultants have typically seen many products succeed and fail across industries, so they can quickly spot issues that you might overlook.

For instance, they might recognise that your value proposition isn’t clearly differentiated, or that your internal process from concept to launch is twice as long as industry best practice. Because they aren’t tied to internal politics or legacy assumptions, consultants will tell you the hard truths and challenge status quo thinking (tactfully, of course). A good consultant can offer unique insight and deliver unfiltered feedback, leveraging their outside experience to spark new ideas and innovation. In a rapidly evolving market, this kind of objective input is invaluable – it can reveal new opportunities (like an unmet customer need) or flag hidden problems before they become failures.

Also, consultants often bring proven frameworks and tools – from market analysis techniques to agile processes – that your team can adopt. This infusion of best practices accelerates learning and improvement, which is vital if your business environment is changing faster than your internal experience can keep up with.

Adapting to change and driving innovation
In fast-moving industries, the only constant is change – be it new customer behaviors, emerging technologies, or economic shifts. Companies that can’t adapt their product strategy quickly risk losing relevance. Product management consulting is important here because it provides agility and innovation muscle. Consultants can help install processes (like continuous customer feedback loops, or rapid prototyping cycles) that make your organisation more responsive and innovative. They also bring market insights and benchmarks; for example, they might share how leading firms are using data analytics or AI in product development, inspiring you to upgrade your own approach. Importantly, consultants keep the customer front and center, even as the market evolves.

A famous Harvard Business School study found that 95% of new products fail due to a lack of market research and consumer insight. That statistic underlines that no matter how advanced your tech or how grand your plans, if you misjudge what the customer wants, the product will likely flop. In complex environments, it’s easy for teams to become internally focused and lose sight of the customer.

Consultants act as a constant reminder and resource to drive a customer-centric approach – through techniques like voice-of-customer research, persona development and usability testing. By doing so, they help your company innovate in ways that truly resonate with the market, rather than just innovating for innovation’s sake. This customer-aligned innovation is often what separates products that thrive from those that gather dust on the shelf.

Leadership support and confidence
Finally, consider the emotional and leadership aspect. As a senior leader, you carry the weight of your product decisions. When things aren’t going well – say a key product is late to market or a new launch underperforms – the pressure and uncertainty can be immense. Product management consulting provides an experienced partner to share that burden.

A good consultant doesn’t just hand over a strategy document and disappear; they work alongside you and your team, functioning almost as an interim product executive who is deeply invested in your success. This partnership can bring a leader tremendous relief and confidence. You gain a sounding board for tough decisions, someone who can validate your instincts or caution you against a risky move with evidence. In complex or crisis situations, consultants also provide structured problem-solving at a time you need it most.

So, product management consulting is important not just for the technical and strategic value, but for the leadership value – it empowers you with clarity, reduces uncertainty and bolsters your resolve to drive the product and the business forward.

When should you consider bringing in a product management consultant?

How do you know if your organisation could benefit from external product management consulting? While every company is different, there are common symptoms and scenarios that signal it might be time to seek outside help. Below are some telltale signs for a senior leader to watch for. If several of these ring true, engaging a product management consultant could be a wise move:

Growing product complexity (and chaos)
Your product portfolio or development pipeline has become very complex or unwieldy and it’s straining your current management processes. Perhaps you’re scrambling to launch products on time or frequently missing key milestones due to the complexity. You might have so many products (or product variations) that it’s unclear which products are truly the priority or which ones are underperforming. This often happens as companies scale or expand globally – suddenly there are multiple teams, versions and markets in play and you lose clear line of sight.

If you feel like you’re constantly firefighting – rushing from one product crisis to another – or drowning in a sea of SKUs and projects, a consultant can help bring order. They can introduce portfolio management techniques to evaluate and simplify your offerings and implement processes to handle complexity without the chaos.

Poor innovation ROI
You’re investing in new products or innovations, but the returns just aren’t there. Maybe you’ve had a string of product launches that failed to meet their business case (i.e. the revenue or market share they were supposed to deliver never materialised). It could be that your R&D spend is high, but you’re not seeing proportional impact on the top line or customer satisfaction. Low innovation ROI is a red flag that something is broken in the product strategy or development approach.

Common culprits include weak product-market fit, misallocation of resources to low-impact ideas, or inefficient development cycles that inflate costs.

If you find yourself questioning “why do we keep pouring money into product X and not getting results?”, it’s a good time to bring in a consultant. They can perform a frank assessment to figure out why the payoff is lacking and help reorient your innovation strategy toward more profitable opportunities.

Siloed teams and lack of alignment
Internally, your teams might be working hard but not together. Silo mentality can cripple product efforts – for example, the engineering team builds whatever they find cool or feasible, the marketing team is briefed late and struggles to pitch the product and the sales team complains the product doesn’t match what customers ask for.

If you observe that product development, marketing, sales, customer service and other groups are not in sync, it’s a strong signal you could benefit from product management consulting.

Perhaps ownership of the product portfolio is unclear, leading to turf wars or gaps in decision-making. Or strategies get “lost in translation” between departments. Siloed operations not only slow things down, they also breed frustration and reduce quality – the left hand doesn’t know what the right is doing.

A consultant can act as an impartial facilitator to break down these silos. They will establish clear roles and responsibilities (e.g., who “owns” product decisions vs. who provides input), set up cross-functional forums for communication and ensure everyone is aligned on the same product objectives.

Lack of customer insight
You suspect that your product decisions are being made in a vacuum, without deep customer insight – and that’s a dangerous place to be. Perhaps your team hasn’t done thorough market research in a while, or you’re entering a new market segment where you don’t fully understand customer needs. Maybe you’re seeing warning signs, like increasing customer complaints, poor product reviews, or sales opportunities lost to competitors who seem more in tune with what customers want.

A lack of customer insight often underlies product failures. In fact, as noted earlier, research indicates that 95% of product innovations fail due to insufficient understanding of real customer needs. If you realise your team is making a lot of assumptions about the market (and those assumptions aren’t validated), it’s time to consider a consultant. Product management consultants are adept at injecting voice-of-customer data into your strategy. They can organise customer interviews, surveys and data analysis to unearth what your buyers truly value and then adjust your product plans accordingly.

If you feel uneasy that you’re “flying blind” or relying on gut feel about the customer, an external consultant can quickly illuminate the path with factual insights. This will not only prevent costly missteps but also ensure your products develop features and experiences that genuinely resonate with your target audience.

No clear product strategy or process

Some organisations find themselves without a formal product management framework at all – especially true for startups or SMEs that grew quickly without installing robust processes, or divisions of larger companies that historically didn’t handle product development internally. If you’re lacking a clear product roadmap, if decisions feel ad-hoc and reactive, or if there’s confusion over how an idea moves to implementation, that’s a sign of needing help. Likewise, consistently missed deadlines, quality issues, or unpredictable product performance suggest that the underlying process might be immature or broken.

In such cases, bringing in a consultant can jump-start the establishment of a proper product management discipline. They can help you design and implement a scalable process – including how you generate ideas, how you prioritise and plan, how you execute (be it agile or stage-gated) and how you review and learn from outcomes.

Of course, you don’t have to wait for all these problems to become acute before engaging a consultant. The best time to consider product management consulting is often before a critical product initiative or transformation.

For example, if you’re planning to launch a major new product line next year or expand into a new region, bringing in a consultant now to ensure everything is set up for success can save a lot of headache later. It can be proactive – a way to audit and bolster your product approach preemptively. Think of it like hiring a guide before trekking a difficult mountain, rather than calling for rescue mid-climb.

What outcomes and benefits can you expect?

Engaging a product management consultancy is an investment – so it’s fair to ask, what will we get out of it? A well-executed consulting engagement should drive both tangible and intangible benefits for your organisation. Here are some key outcomes and improvements senior leaders can expect when partnering with a strong product management consultant:

A clear, aligned product strategy
Perhaps the most immediate benefit is gaining a sharper strategic vision for your products, one that is tightly aligned to your business goals. By the end of an engagement, you should have clarity on questions like: Which customer segments are we focusing on and why? What value propositions make us stand out? How do our product roadmaps support our growth targets? Consultants help craft a laser-focused product strategy that eliminates meandering or murky objectives. You’ll know where each product (or new idea) fits in the big picture and how it contributes to the company’s mission and metrics. This strategic clarity cascades down through the organisation, replacing confusion with coordinated direction.

Deeper customer insight and product-market fit
A successful product management consulting engagement will leave your company much more in tune with your customers. Expect to develop a far better understanding of customer needs, pain points and preferences – often through new research data or customer feedback that the consultants help gather. This translates into products that fit the market more snugly. You may find that features get adjusted or reprioritised based on these insights, resulting in offerings that resonate more deeply with users. In many cases, companies become what one might call “user whisperers,” able to anticipate and respond to what makes the target audience tick.

The benefit is not just happier customers, but also more efficient development (since you’re building the right things) and a stronger competitive position (because your products hit the mark).

Improved cross-functional collaboration
One of the transformative outcomes of bringing in product management experts is the breaking down of silos and a new level of cross-functional teamwork. Through the alignment efforts and process changes described earlier, you should see previously disparate teams working more cohesively towards product goals. For example, instead of sales, marketing and engineering each doing their own thing, they’ll be synchronising plans and informing each other early and often.

A concrete benefit here is greater organisational readiness for product launches and changes. Consultants often implement mechanisms to increase visibility – so that when a new product is set to launch or an update rolls out, all parts of the business (from supply chain to customer support) are prepared to contribute. No more last-minute scrambles because one department was out of the loop. This alignment not only smooths execution but also fosters a sense of shared purpose among employees, which boosts morale and efficiency. Leaders can expect a reduction in internal friction and a boost in overall execution speed when everyone is pulling in the same direction.

Faster time-to-market and higher success rates
Engaging a product management consultancy should directly impact your speed and success in innovation. With better processes and alignment, you can accelerate development cycles and eliminate bottlenecks, resulting in faster time-to-market for new products. Also, those products are more likely to succeed once in the market.

You can realistically expect higher success rates for new launches, meaning more of your product introductions hit their adoption and revenue targets (or whatever metrics define success for you). By applying best practices, consultants help avoid the pitfalls that cause delays and failures. Maybe they helped you institute agile sprints, or better risk management, or more rigorous market validation – all these contribute to getting products out quicker and with a better market reception.

The net effect is a stronger innovation ROI: more bang for each buck (and hour) invested in R&D. This benefit is something you can often measure – e.g., a 20% reduction in average launch timeframe, or an increase in the percentage of new products meeting their goals. For a leader, there are few better feelings than seeing new innovations actually delivering on their promises and delivering faster than before.

Optimised product portfolio (and resources)
A consultant will also help you optimise your product portfolio management, which means you’ll be making smarter decisions about where to invest and where to pull back. By the end of the engagement, you should have a much clearer picture of which products (or projects) are winners, which need improvement and which may be unnecessarily eating up resources. Expect to trim the “tail” of underperforming products – those legacy offerings or low-volume SKUs that add complexity but little value – thus freeing up resources (money, talent, production capacity) to focus on more promising opportunities.

You’ll also have processes to prevent that tail from growing back (for instance, criteria to regularly review and cull products that don’t meet thresholds). Additionally, consultants will help ensure your pipeline of new product development is right-sized for your capacity, balancing the number of projects with the resources you actually have. This means no more stretched teams juggling 15 projects when they realistically can only execute 5 well. The benefit is a more balanced, profitable portfolio. You’re maximising the value of your investments by doubling down on what works and smartly managing or eliminating what doesn’t.

Many companies see improved profitability and growth as a direct result – the portfolio as a whole starts to yield better margins and strategic positioning once it’s pruned and aligned.

Enhanced metrics and accountability
With the introduction of product management discipline, you will gain better metrics and oversight of product performance. Consultants help define the right KPIs (e.g. innovation pipeline velocity, product profitability, customer satisfaction scores, etc.) and set up dashboards or reports for ongoing tracking.

As a result, you as a leader can monitor progress in near-real-time and hold teams accountable to clear targets. This transparency means no more unpleasant surprises at the end of the quarter – you’ll have early warning indicators if a product is veering off course and the ability to course-correct proactively.

Also, teams themselves become more data-driven and accountable; when everyone knows what “success” looks like in measurable terms, it’s easier to focus efforts and objectively evaluate outcomes. Over time, this leads to a culture of continuous improvement, where decisions are made on evidence and results are celebrated (or learned from) in an open way.

Sustainable processes and team capability
Perhaps the most long-lasting benefit you can expect is that the improvements will stick. A good product management consulting engagement doesn’t just provide a one-time boost; it leaves you with sustainable processes and a stronger team. Your internal capabilities in product management will be noticeably higher. Product teams will be fluent in the new frameworks and practices. Other departments will also be more product-aware and collaborative. In fact, your entire organisation will have a more mature approach to managing products.

Oliver Wight, for example, validates that a client’s processes are embedded as the new “way of doing things” – that’s a benchmark of true sustainability. You should expect nothing less. The consultant’s end goal is typically to “work themselves out of a job” by enabling your people to carry the torch independently.

As a leader, you’ll benefit from this in the long run: you gain an organisation that can continue to execute and innovate effectively, without constant hand-holding. Additionally, your teams will likely feel more confident and empowered – they’ve learned from experts and seen success, which builds their capability and morale. This positions your company for ongoing success well beyond the initial consulting project.

Partnering for lasting product success

Product management consulting is more than a buzzword or a band-aid solution – it’s a strategic partnership that can elevate your organisation’s ability to deliver winning products consistently.

For senior leaders, the decision to bring in a product management consultant can be pivotal. It’s an opportunity to lighten the load of uncertainty and gain a trusted ally dedicated to your success. The right consultant understands the emotional weight of responsibility you carry and will work alongside you to instill clarity and confidence. Rather than adding another layer of complexity, they help cut through complexity. Rather than offering quick fixes, they focus on lasting change – embedding new capabilities in your team so that success continues long after the engagement ends.

As Oliver Wight’s own philosophy states, it’s about “teams, not just processes” and “long-term benefits, not just quick wins”.

Ready to take control of your product strategy?
Speak to our consultants to explore how product management support could drive better outcomes across your portfolio.

---